The Optimist

  • October 15Follow us on Twitter and Instagram

  • October 15South has 5 Lilly Scholarship finalists!

  • September 11Finals are Nov. 1 and 2

Can I be Jewish and still love Christmas?

Jen Crystal, Staff Writer

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






  I’m Jewish. For as long as I can remember, I’ve spent my Christmases eating Chinese food and watching movies, and yet, I’ve always dreamed of more.

I’ve fantasized of a Christmas tree complete with all of the trimmings. Of tinsel and ornaments. Of lights and a star. Of Christmas songs humming in the background. Of everyone singing along. I want to make Christmas cookies and wear ugly sweaters. I so desperately wish to be a part of this magnificent holiday, but I am plagued with feelings of guilt for thinking this way. Is it wrong to love the traditions and customs of another religion? Not only that, but is it wrong to wish to celebrate them?

I like to blame society for my undevoted thoughts, as I like to with most of my problems. I tell myself, “It’s not that you love Christmas. You just love the commercialized aspects of it” and, in a way, that’s true. I, as a Jewish girl, will probably never fully understand what it means to grow up Christian. To wake up Christmas morning hoping to catch a glimpse of Santa is an aspect of most peoples’ childhood that was never a part of mine. No matter where I go, it seems that Christmas cannot escape me. With the arrival of the holidays comes the Christmas sales, the commercials, the Christmas carols and the gifts.  When Hanukkah rolls around, there is a run on potatoes, donuts and candles. There are no carolers, commercials or movies. There aren’t even a lot presents (only eight small gifts which I believe is a way to cheat out the Jewish kids).   

I like to fancy myself the  Holiday Armadillo. When the holidays roll around, it’s like I’m on steroids. I am suddenly needed in a million places at once, and I don’t even mind. All throughout the holiday season, I’m on a Christmas high in which I feel invincible (don’t do drugs kids). I have never once been on a Hanukkah high, nor have I ever heard of such a thing.

I truly am faced with an ethical dilemma. Although my family is not extremely religious, I’m still caught at a cultural crossroads. However, I have been hit with a wave of acceptance. I think I’ll always be a Christmas-loving-Jew, but perhaps my problems would be solved if I married a nice Christian boy…

Happy Hanukkah.

 

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

1 Comment

One Response to “Can I be Jewish and still love Christmas?”

  1. Olivia Baker on December 19th, 2017 10:51 am

    I don’t often read The Optimist, but I have often found myself with this same dilemma! I really appreciate someone writing about this and being able to relate to something like this, even if it is kind of silly. It annoys me sometimes when people try to join cultures that they are not apart of, but I, hypocritically to be fair, have always wanted to join in Christmas. Thank you for writing this, and making it well written and funny.

    -O

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • Can I be Jewish and still love Christmas?

    News

    Math League is on the rise

  • Can I be Jewish and still love Christmas?

    Showcase

    South girls fall to Center Grove in PKs

  • Can I be Jewish and still love Christmas?

    Showcase

    South boys, girls run to 2nd place finish at sectionals (gallery)

  • Can I be Jewish and still love Christmas?

    News

    South administration outlines new JUUL policies

  • Can I be Jewish and still love Christmas?

    Showcase

    South tennis sweeps Sectionals

  • Can I be Jewish and still love Christmas?

    Showcase

    Upperclassmen visit the college fair

  • Can I be Jewish and still love Christmas?

    Showcase

    South football falls to Columbus North, 35-52.

  • Can I be Jewish and still love Christmas?

    Showcase

    Homecoming king and queen crowned

  • Can I be Jewish and still love Christmas?

    Showcase

    National Honor Society hosts blood drive

  • Can I be Jewish and still love Christmas?

    News

    Parking woes in the front lot

The student news site of Bloomington High School South
Can I be Jewish and still love Christmas?